Progresos y retos de la Toxicología Genética / Progress and challenges of Genetic Toxicology

Resumen: Esta revisión resume los principales avances de la citogenética y proporciona una perspectiva sobre el futuro de la toxicología genética, desde el pasado, presente y futuro, tanto desde el punto de vista genético como epigenético. Los principios de la citogenética clásica han evolucionado con el tiempo, interactuando con enfoques de toxicología para dar lugar a la toxicología genética o mutagénesis ambiental. Actualmente, están surgiendo estudios toxicogenómicos basados en estudios de toxicología genética estándar, y uno de los principales objetivos de la toxicogenómica es detectar relaciones entre cambios en la expresión génica global y criterios de valoración toxicológicos, con el fin de comprender el papel de las interacciones gen-ambiente en la enfermedad. Para alcanzar este objetivo, la toxicogenómica combina la toxicología, la genética, tecnologías de perfiles moleculares de alto rendimiento como la transcriptómica, proteómica, metabolómica y la bioinformática. En este campo, muchas limitaciones restringen el papel de los nuevos hallazgos y enfoques. Por ejemplo, el costo de las nuevas tecnologías; sin embargo, su aplicación contribuirá a una mejor comprensión de las interacciones gen-ambiente y de esta manera, establecer políticas orientadas a prevenir riesgos para la salud, para que se viva una vida más saludable en un ambiente más favorable. (AU)

This review summarizes the main advances of cytogenetic and provides a perspective on the future of genetic toxicology, reviewing from past, present, and future, both genetics and epigenetic point of view. The principles of classical cytogenetics have evolved over time, interacting with toxicology approaches to give rise to genetic toxicology or environmental mutagenesis. Currently, toxicogenomic studies are emerging based on standard genetic toxicology studies, and one major goal of toxicogenomic is to detect relationships between changes in global gene expression and toxicological endpoints, in order to understand the role of gene-environment interactions in disease. To reach this goal, toxicogenomics combines toxicology, genetic, with genomics or other high throughput molecular profiling technologies such as transcriptomics, proteomics, metabolomics, and bioinformatics. In this field, many limitations are restricting the role of the novel findings and approaches. For example, the cost of new technologies; however, its application will contribute to a better understanding of gene-environment interactions and in this way, establish policies aimed at preventing health risks, so that a healthier life is lived in a friendlier environment. (AU)

Genome-wide toxicogenomic study of the lanthanides sheds light on the selective toxicity mechanisms associated with critical materials.

Lanthanides are a series of critical elements widely used in multiple industries, such as optoelectronics and healthcare. Although initially considered to be of low toxicity, concerns have emerged during the last few decades over their impact on human health. The toxicological profile of these metals, however, has been incompletely characterized, with most studies to date solely focusing on one or two elements within the group. In the current study, we assessed potential toxicity mechanisms in the lanthanide series using a functional toxicogenomics approach in baker's yeast, which shares many cellular pathways and functions with humans. We screened the homozygous deletion pool of 4,291 Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains with the lanthanides and identified both common and unique functional effects of these metals. Three very different trends were observed within the lanthanide series, where deletions of certain proteins on membranes and organelles had no effect on the cellular response to early lanthanides while inducing yeast sensitivity and resistance to middle and late lanthanides, respectively. Vesicle-mediated transport (primarily endocytosis) was highlighted by both gene ontology and pathway enrichment analyses as one of the main functions disturbed by the majority of the metals. Protein-protein network analysis indicated that yeast response to lanthanides relied on proteins that participate in regulatory paths used for calcium (and other biologically relevant cations), and lanthanide toxicity included disruption of biosynthetic pathways by enzyme inhibition. Last, multiple genes and proteins identified in the network analysis have human orthologs, suggesting that those may also be targeted by lanthanides in humans.

The promise of toxicogenomics for genetic toxicology: past, present and future.

Toxicogenomics, the application of genomics to toxicology, was described as 'a new era' for toxicology. Standard toxicity tests typically involve a number of short-term bioassays that are costly, time consuming, require large numbers of animals and generally focus on a single end point. Toxicogenomics was heralded as a way to improve the efficiency of toxicity testing by assessing gene regulation across the genome, allowing rapid classification of compounds based on characteristic expression profiles. Gene expression microarrays could measure and characterise genome-wide gene expression changes in a single study and while transcriptomic profiles that can discriminate between genotoxic and non-genotoxic carcinogens have been identified, challenges with the approach limited its application. As such, toxicogenomics did not transform the field of genetic toxicology in the way it was predicted. More recently, next generation sequencing (NGS) technologies have revolutionised genomics owing to the fact that hundreds of billions of base pairs can be sequenced simultaneously cheaper and quicker than traditional Sanger methods. In relation to genetic toxicology, and thousands of cancer genomes have been sequenced with single-base substitution mutational signatures identified, and mutation signatures have been identified following treatment of cells with known or suspected environmental carcinogens. RNAseq has been applied to detect transcriptional changes following treatment with genotoxins; modified RNAseq protocols have been developed to identify adducts in the genome and Duplex sequencing is an example of a technique that has recently been developed to accurately detect mutation. Machine learning, including MutationSeq and SomaticSeq, has also been applied to somatic mutation detection and improvements in automation and/or the application of machine learning algorithms may allow high-throughput mutation sequencing in the future. This review will discuss the initial promise of transcriptomics for genetic toxicology, and how the development of NGS technologies and new machine learning algorithms may finally realise that promise.

Salud mental y salud ambiental. Una visión prospectiva. Informe SESPAS 2020 / Mental health and environmental health. A prospective view. SESPAS Report 2020

El ambiente ha sido, desde los albores de la psiquiatría, un factor fundamental en el estudio y la comprensión de las enfermedades mentales. La relación entre genoma y ambiente ha constituido tradicionalmente un tema central en la investigación de la etiopatogenia de los problemas de salud mental y en la concepción misma de esta. En su aplicación a la psicopatología y a la salud mental, la ambiómica psiquiátrica se ha definido como «el estudio de las condiciones y procesos ambientales que promueven la salud mental o incrementan los riesgos de trastornos mentales». Sin embargo, la salud ambiental, al menos en España y en relación con sus competencias dentro del sistema de salud general, ha centrado su atención en los aspectos relativos a los riesgos ligados a la contaminación física, química o biológica del aire, el agua o la tierra, así como a su correlato alimenticio. Aunque los riesgos ambientales, como la calidad del aire, las temperaturas extremas, el ruido, el cambio climático y distintos tóxicos ambientales, pueden desempeñar un papel muy importante, difícilmente pueden ser identificados como elementos etiopatogénicos únicos. Este trabajo revisa la literatura reciente sobre la investigación ambiental y los problemas de morbimortalidad psiquiátrica. Si bien los resultados son poco concluyentes, las futuras líneas de investigación deberían considerar una colaboración interdisciplinaria más ágil, que permita, por un lado, entender mejor la enfermedad mental, y por otro, avanzar desde la salud ambiental «tradicional» a una que contemple los factores ambientales de tipo social abordando el concepto aún poco estudiado de «contaminación social»

Since the dawn of psychiatry, the environment has been an essential factor in the study and understanding of mental illness. Traditionally, the interrelationship between genome and environment has been a central theme in research on the etiopathogenesis of mental health problems and in the very conception of mental health. In its application to psychopathology and mental health, psychiatric enviromics was defined as «the study of environmental conditions and processes that promote mental health or increase the risk of developing mental disorders». However, environmental health -at least in Spain and in connection with its powers within the Spanish General Health System- has paid attention to aspects pertaining to risks associated with the physical, chemical and biological pollution of the air, the water and the ground, as well as to its correlation with food pollution. Although environmental risks such as air quality, extreme temperatures, noise, climate change and various environmental toxicants can play a particularly important role, they can hardly be identified as single etiopathogenic elements. This work reviews the recent literature on environmental research and problems of psychiatric morbidity and mortality. Although the results are inconclusive, future lines of research should consider a more agile interdisciplinary collaboration, allowing, on the one hand, a better understanding of mental illness and, on the other hand, to be able to shift from "traditional" environmental health to an environmental health that takes social environmental factors into account and seriously addresses the still little studied concept of "social pollution"

Toxicogenomics: A 2020 Vision.

Toxicogenomics (TGx) has contributed significantly to toxicology and now has great potential to support moves towards animal-free approaches in regulatory decision making. Here, we discuss in vitro TGx systems and their potential impact on risk assessment. We raise awareness of the rapid advancement of genomics technologies, which generates novel genomics features essential for enhanced risk assessment. We specifically emphasize the importance of reproducibility in utilizing TGx in the regulatory setting. We also highlight the role of machine learning (particularly deep learning) in developing TGx-based predictive models. Lastly, we touch on the topics of how TGx approaches could facilitate adverse outcome pathways (AOP) development and enhance read-across strategies to further regulatory application. Finally, we summarize current efforts to develop TGx for risk assessment and set out remaining challenges.

Occupational chemical exposure and diabetes mellitus risk.

Diabetes mellitus (DM) is a group of metabolic diseases that may originate from an interaction between genetic and lifestyle risk factors. However, the possible role of occupational chemical exposures in the disease development and progression remains unclear. Therefore, this review aimed to provide a comprehensive evaluation of the relationship between occupational exposure to specific chemical substances or industrial activities and DM morbidity and mortality outcomes. Although some positive findings may support the diabetogenic role of certain pesticides and dioxins in different workplaces, the variable conditions of exposure, the lack of quantitative environmental or biological monitoring data and the different outcomes evaluated do not allow defining a specific exposure-disease causality. Therefore, further epidemiological studies will be necessary to adequately assess modes of action for different substances, dose-response relationships as well as individual susceptibility factors potentially affecting the exposure-disease continuum. Overall, this appears important to adequately assess, communicate and manage risks in occupational chemical exposure settings with the aim to protect workers and build healthier job conditions for diabetic employees.

Toxicogenomics in Environmental Science.

This chapter reviews the current knowledge and recent progress in the field of environmental, aquatic ecotoxicogenomics with a focus on transcriptomic methods. In ecotoxicogenomics the omics technologies are applied for the detection and assessment of adverse effects in the environment, and thus are to be distinguished from omics used in human toxicology [Snape et al., Aquat Toxicol 67:143-154, 2004]. Transcriptomic methods in ecotoxicology are applied to gain a mechanistic understanding of toxic effects on organisms or populations, and thus aim to bridge the gap between cause and effect. A worthwhile effect-based interpretation of stressor induced changes on the transcriptome is based on the principle of phenotypic-anchoring [Paules, Environ Health Perspect 111:A338-A339, 2003]. Thereby, changes on the transcriptomic level can only be identified as effects if they are clearly linked to a specific stressor-induced effect on the macroscopic level. By integrating those macroscopic and transcriptomic effects, conclusions on the effect-inducing type of the stressor can be drawn. Stressor-specific effects on the transcriptomic level can be identified as stressor-specific induced pathways, transcriptomic patterns, or stressors-specific genetic biomarkers. In this chapter, examples of the combined application of macroscopic and transcriptional effects for the identification of environmental stressors, such as aquatic pollutants, are given and discussed. By means of these examples, challenges on the way to a standardized application of transcriptomics in ecotoxicology are discussed. This is also done against the background of the application of transcriptomic methods in environmental regulation such as the EU regulation Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals (REACH).

Meta-analysis of transcriptomic responses as a means to identify pulmonary disease outcomes for engineered nanomaterials.

BACKGROUND: The increasing use of engineered nanomaterials (ENMs) of varying physical and chemical characteristics poses a great challenge for screening and assessing the potential pathology induced by these materials, necessitating novel toxicological approaches. Toxicogenomics measures changes in mRNA levels in cells and tissues following exposure to toxic substances. The resulting information on altered gene expression profiles, associated pathways, and the doses at which these changes occur, are used to identify the underlying mechanisms of toxicity and to predict disease outcomes. We evaluated the applicability of toxicogenomics data in identifying potential lung-specific (genomic datasets are currently available from experiments where mice have been exposed to various ENMs through this common route of exposure) disease outcomes following exposure to ENMs. METHODS: Seven toxicogenomics studies describing mouse pulmonary responses over time following intra-tracheal exposure to increasing doses of carbon nanotubes (CNTs), carbon black, and titanium dioxide (TiO2) nanoparticles of varying properties were examined to understand underlying mechanisms of toxicity. mRNA profiles from these studies were compared to the publicly available datasets of 15 other mouse models of lung injury/diseases induced by various agents including bleomycin, ovalbumin, TNFα, lipopolysaccharide, bacterial infection, and welding fumes to delineate the implications of ENM-perturbed biological processes to disease pathogenesis in lungs. RESULTS: The meta-analysis revealed two distinct clusters-one driven by TiO2 and the other by CNTs. Unsupervised clustering of the genes showing significant expression changes revealed that CNT response clustered with bleomycin injury and bacterial infection models, both of which are known to induce lung fibrosis, in a post-exposure-time dependent manner, irrespective of the CNT's physical-chemical properties. TiO2 samples clustered separately from CNTs and disease models. CONCLUSIONS: These results indicate that in the absence of apical toxicity data, a tiered strategy beginning with short term, in vivo tissue transcriptomics profiling can effectively and efficiently screen new ENMs that have a higher probability of inducing pulmonary pathogenesis.

The role of microRNAs in toxicology.

A number of environmental toxicants affect our health through physical, biological or chemical mechanisms. There is growing evidence indicating that microRNA (miRNA) plays an important role in toxicogenomics, disease aetiology and the effect of toxicants. This article summarises recent findings on miRNAs associated with various toxicants and those targeted in the development of therapeutics. Environmental epigenetic studies have revealed the role of miRNAs in the regulation of gene activities induced by environmental changes after exposure to toxic substances. Toxicant-induced changes in miRNA expression have a potential to be informative markers in the evaluation of toxicant risks. miRNAs are now considered to be predictive biomarkers or indicators of tissue injury due to toxicant exposure; thus, miRNAs can also be utilised as therapeutic targets.

Toward predictive models for drug-induced liver injury in humans: are we there yet?

Drug-induced liver injury (DILI) is a frequent cause for the termination of drug development programs and a leading reason of drug withdrawal from the marketplace. Unfortunately, the current preclinical testing strategies, including the regulatory-required animal toxicity studies or simple in vitro tests, are insufficiently powered to predict DILI in patients reliably. Notably, the limited predictive power of such testing strategies is mostly attributed to the complex nature of DILI, a poor understanding of its mechanism, a scarcity of human hepatotoxicity data and inadequate bioinformatics capabilities. With the advent of high-content screening assays, toxicogenomics and bioinformatics, multiple end points can be studied simultaneously to improve prediction of clinically relevant DILIs. This review focuses on the current state of efforts in developing predictive models from diverse data sources for potential use in detecting human hepatotoxicity, and also aims to provide perspectives on how to further improve DILI prediction.

Where will genetic toxicology testing be in 30 years' time? Summary report of the 25th Industrial Genotoxicity Group Meeting, Royal Society of Medicine, London, November 9, 2011.

A number of influences including legislation, industry and academia have encouraged advances in computational toxicology and high-throughput testing to probe more broadly putative toxicity pathways. The aim of the 25th United Kingdom Mutagen Society (UKEMS) Industrial Genotoxicity Group Annual Meeting 2011 was to explore current and upcoming research tools that may provide new cancer risk estimation approaches and discuss the genotoxicity testing paradigm of the future. The meeting considered whether computer modelling, molecular biology systems and/or adverse outcome pathway approaches can provide more accurate toxicity predictions and whether high-content study data, pluripotent stem cells or new scientific disciplines, such as epigenetics and adductomics, could be integrated into the risk assessment process. With close collaboration between industry, academia and regulators next generation predictive models and high-content tools have the potential to transform genetic toxicology testing in the 21st century.

Current status and future prospects of toxicogenomics in drug discovery.

In drug discovery and development (DDD), the efficacy, safety and cost of new chemical entities are the main concerns of the pharmaceutical industry. Continuously updated and stricter recommendations imposed by regulatory authorities result in greater challenges being faced by the industry. Reliable high-throughput techniques integrated with well-designed analytical tools at all stages of DDD (termed 'next-generation DDD') could be a possible approach to obtaining new drug approval by cutting costs as well as ensuring the highest level of patient safety. In this review, we describe the various components of holistic toxicogenomics with examples of applications, and discuss the various analytical tools and platforms to illustrate the current status and prospects of next-generation DDD.

[Genetic toxicology: findings and challenges].

The review highlights the history of genetic toxicology as a distinct research area, as well as the issues of genetic toxicology and development of its methodology. The strategies and testing patterns of genotoxic compounds are discussed with the purpose of identifying potential human carcinogens, as well as compounds capable of inducing heritable mutations in humans. The main achievements of genetic toxicology in the 20th century are summarized and the challenges of the 21st century are discussed.

Building on the past, shaping the future: the Environmental Mutagenesis and Genomics Society.

In late 2012, the members of the Environmental Mutagen Society voted to change its name to the Environmental Mutagenesis and Genomics Society. Here, we describe the thought process that led to adoption of the new name, which both respects the rich history of a Society founded in 1969 and reflects the many advances in our understanding of the nature and breadth of gene-environment interactions during the intervening 43 years.

A decade of toxicogenomic research and its contribution to toxicological science.

Toxicogenomics enjoyed considerable attention as a ground-breaking addition to conventional toxicology assays at its inception. However, the pace at which toxicogenomics was expected to perform has been tempered in recent years. Next to cost, the lack of advanced knowledge discovery and data mining tools significantly hampered progress in this new field of toxicological sciences. Recently, two of the largest toxicogenomics databases were made freely available to the public. These comprehensive studies are expected to stimulate knowledge discovery and development of novel data mining tools, which are essential to advance this field. In this review, we provide a concise summary of each of these two databases with a brief discussion on the commonalities and differences between them. We place our emphasis on some key questions in toxicogenomics and how these questions can be appropriately addressed with the two databases. Finally, we provide a perspective on the future direction of toxicogenomics and how new technologies such as RNA-Seq may impact this field.

Functional genomics- and network-driven systems biology approaches for pharmacogenomics and toxicogenomics.

Recent advances in genomic technologies have enabled the identification of thousands of genetic variations that are associated with hundreds of complex human diseases or traits in genome-wide association studies (GWAS). The large number of genetic loci uncovered for each disease or trait along with the difficulty in pinpointing the underlying genes and mechanisms further testify to the complexity of human pathophysiology. To alleviate the challenges of GWAS, systems biology approaches have been utilized to map the molecular mechanisms underlying complex human diseases/traits via the integration of genetic variation, functional genomics (such as genetics of gene expression), pathways, and molecular networks. Similar approaches have been applied to a spectrum of drug metabolizing enzymes to discover novel functional genetic variations that affect the expression or activities of these enzymes as well as to define the regulatory pathways/networks of genes involved in drug metabolism and toxicology in key human tissues. We envision that the increased coverage of functional genetic polymorphisms, the availability of drug metabolism-centered gene networks, and the maturing methodologies previously developed for understanding complex human diseases can be applied to pharmacogenomic and toxicogenomic studies to further our understanding of inter-individual variability in drug efficacy and toxicity and eventually help direct personalized medicine.

Current and future use of genomics data in toxicology: opportunities and challenges for regulatory applications.

Toxicogenomics is the application of toxicology, genetics, molecular biology and environmental health to describe the response of organisms to environmental stimuli. The field of toxicogenomics has developed over the past 15 years mainly due to advances in toxicology, molecular genetics and cell biology. Its prospective use to resolve crucial data gaps and data inconsistencies could improve risk assessment by providing additional data to increase the understanding of mechanisms and modes of action (MOA) and enhance the reliability of dose-response extrapolation. Thus, toxicogenomics holds promise for advancing the scientific basis of risk assessments. However, one of the current issues is how genomic/transcriptional data is being used to further describe a MOA for oncogenicity and, in turn, its potential uses in cancer risk assessment. This commentary identifies how toxicogenomics could be used on a case by case basis to add information to a MOA addressing both the opportunities and challenges this technology holds. In addition, some pitfalls to avoid in the generation and interpretation of toxicogenomic data and validation issues that need to be addressed before toxicogenomics can be used in the risk assessment process and regulatory decisions are discussed.

The embryonic stem cell test combined with toxicogenomics as an alternative testing model for the assessment of developmental toxicity.

One of the most studied in vitro alternative testing methods for identification of developmental toxicity is the embryonic stem cell test (EST). Although the EST has been formally validated, the applicability domain as well as the predictability of the model needs further study to allow successful implementation of the EST as an alternative testing method in regulatory toxicity testing. Genomics technologies have already provided a proof of principle of their value in identification of toxicants such as carcinogenic compounds. Also within the EST, gene expression profiling has shown its value in the identification of developmental toxicity and in the evaluation of factors critical for risk assessment, such as dose and time responses. It is expected that the implementation of genomics into the EST will provide a more detailed end point evaluation as compared to the classical morphological scoring of differentiation cultures. Therefore, genomics may contribute to improvement of the EST, both in terms of definition of its applicability domain as well as its predictive capacity. In the present review, we present the progress that has been made with regard to the prediction of developmental toxicity using the EST combined with transcriptomics. Furthermore, we discuss the developments of additional aspects required for further optimization of the EST, including kinetics, the use of human embryonic stem cells (ESC) and computational toxicology. Finally, the current and future use of the EST model for prediction of developmental toxicity in testing strategies and in regulatory toxicity evaluations is discussed.

Genetic toxicology in the 21st century: reflections and future directions.

A symposium at the 40th anniversary of the Environmental Mutagen Society, held from October 24-28, 2009 in St. Louis, MO, surveyed the current status and future directions of genetic toxicology. This article summarizes the presentations and provides a perspective on the future. An abbreviated history is presented, highlighting the current standard battery of genotoxicity assays and persistent challenges. Application of computational toxicology to safety testing within a regulatory setting is discussed as a means for reducing the need for animal testing and human clinical trials, and current approaches and applications of in silico genotoxicity screening approaches across the pharmaceutical industry were surveyed and are reported here. The expanded use of toxicogenomics to illuminate mechanisms and bridge genotoxicity and carcinogenicity, and new public efforts to use high-throughput screening technologies to address lack of toxicity evaluation for the backlog of thousands of industrial chemicals in the environment are detailed. The Tox21 project involves coordinated efforts of four U.S. Government regulatory/research entities to use new and innovative assays to characterize key steps in toxicity pathways, including genotoxic and nongenotoxic mechanisms for carcinogenesis. Progress to date, highlighting preliminary test results from the National Toxicology Program is summarized. Finally, an overview is presented of ToxCast™, a related research program of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, using a broad array of high throughput and high content technologies for toxicity profiling of environmental chemicals, and computational toxicology modeling. Progress and challenges, including the pressing need to incorporate metabolic activation capability, are summarized.

Toxicogenomics for the prediction of toxicity related to herbs from traditional Chinese medicine.

Toxicogenomics represents the integration of genomics and toxicology to investigate the interaction between genes and environmental stress in human health. It is a scientific field that studies how the genome is involved in responses to environmental stressors and toxicants. The patterns of altered gene expression that are caused by specific exposures or disease outcomes reveal how toxicants may act and cause disease. Nowadays, toxicogenomics faces great challenges in discriminating the molecular basis of toxicity. We do believe that advances in this field will eventually allow us to describe all the toxicological interactions that occur within a living system. Toxicogenomic responses of a toxic agent in one species (e.g., laboratory animals) may predict the mode of action in another species (e.g., humans) (predictive toxicology). Development and application of toxicogenomic databases and new bioinformatics tools are among the most important aspects of toxicogenomic research which will facilitate sharing and interpretation of the huge amount of biological information generated in this field. Medicinal herbs have played an important role in pharmacy from ancient to modern times. Nowadays, there is a revival of interest in medicinal plants and an increasing scientific interest in bioactive natural products. Medicinal herbs are usually considered to be nontoxic. However, the consumption of herbs could produce prominent toxic effects either due to inherent toxicity or to contaminants (heavy metals, microorganisms, pesticides, toxic organic solvents, radioactivity, etc.). Therefore, a critical assessment of their toxicity is an urgent issue. This review explores the field of toxicogenomics, pinpoints some of its research approaches and describes the challenges it faces. In particular, Chinese herbal preparations have been implicated.